Trust is a Facade in the Banking World
What is Trust? In the business world is a fiduciary
matter to manage and take responsibility for once asset based on their interest
and objective. However, this fiduciary act has some errors, deception and fraud,
hence the world we live in, some people live to the quote “take what you can and
give nothing back” essentially describe in Wells Fargo account fraud and the
CEO, directors and senior managers motive to close the secrecy.
In the fraud story, Wells Fargo was charge for million
in saving and checking account transaction fraudulent, where the company
increase the accounts to one customer to have 8 accounts with the objective to
obtain high income and commission, this is done by transferring funds from checking
account to checking account in a cycle which the customer obtains additional
fees, credit and expenses unaware of the transaction. The company was penalized
around $185 million from the fraudulent action and the executives are currently
charge on criminal and civil lawsuits.
This is highly an unprecedented manner and ignorant
action by the executive to perform sufficient cross- selling to increase
wealth. Then the executives just blamed the employees and retail managers based
on the fraudulent, then fired them. We all know that news media did a news
coverage on actual incident that it is not the employees and retail manager
fault, as they were pressurized by the executives and directors to perform this
fraudulent scheme and get fired from this action. This is highly unethical and
confirms the word stupidity to the executive of Wells Fargo company.
Hence, another example of greed destroys us all.
Followed by fraud techniques enacted in Wells Fargo such as manipulation of
revenue and pressurising employees to be fired.
The question is that, why government took so long to
detect Wells Fargo or any company’s fraudulent activity? Is it because the
difficulties to detect fraud with hundreds of companies in the country? It
should not be! Unless the bank provides financial reporting and internal
managerial report manipulation which lied to the government and an ingenious
move.
If I was the financial manager in Wells Fargo, to
achieve the target sales, the company should attract as many customers as
possible, to put specified accounts to the customer and promote Wells Fargo
products to be sold to clients, such as giving them insurance investment,
credit card promotion such as in using Wells Fargo credit card the customer
will obtain 10% discount in product spending online and from retailers, and persuading
customers to issue a mortgage which overall should amplify Wells Fargo revenue
stream. Customers also include other
banks to invest in Credit Default Swaps or Interest Rate Swaps, which should
comply with Wells Fargo revenue stream and financial relationship with other
banks.
In terms of investors, Wells Fargo should provide safe
investment and sufficient capital requirement to cover probable loss in loan
transfer default and trading book losses. Thus, Wells Fargo should attract
investors to invest in its profitable assets such as bonds and shares which
amplify company’s fund to perform further productive investment, such as
further lending in mortgages, insurances, and portfolio wealth maximization by
diversification.
I am highly interested in the finance and banking
industry, hence after I graduate my bachelor’s degree, I will apply a job in
Barclays Bank as a Savings, Wealth and Investment Manager, because the bank is
a successful financial institution with sufficient corporate governance and
often satisfying their employees and clients. I am also a pragmatist individual
and I like to innovate, thus currently I have an idea to amplify a banks market
efficiency and wealth maximization by performing an Artificial Intelligence
programming to Barclays customers mobile application, computerise risk management and volatility forecasting, and
asset algorithm to be more efficient and able to use all financial formulas as
fast as possible on predicting possible future outcome.
In terms of customers, AI should be able to monitor
customer interest, such as if a customer take a picture of a car post on his
social media such as Facebook or Instagram and having interest on the car,
however the customer does not have the income to buy, the AI will obtain that
information, send to the banker which the banker will analyse the customer
financial and credit report, and if all are sufficient the banker will provide
a car loan digitally to the client, enabling Barclays increase in future
revenue stream and the customer able to buy the car and pay the short term loan.
Based on investor, the AI will continuously have 24
hours risk management on investor portfolio and analysing possible stock price
to increase or decrease in the future, which the AI will inform the investor by
the banks application which the investor is fully informed and educated
regarding their portfolio financial sustainability and stock correlation, thus a
sufficient decision making by the investor to buy more Barclays assets which
should achieve client satisfaction and Barclays wealth maximization.
But
right now I know what you might be thinking, all technologies are manipulated
by human hands, so what if the AI is manipulated and exploited by a bank?
Such
as Wells Fargo did with manipulating digital checking and saving accounts.
This is a problem of technological and
financial ethics, because AI can control algorithm and even customer accounts
easily to amplify a banks revenue or employees’ income. Such as what if there
is a rouge banker who persuade many clients to invest on a bank securities or
digital deposit accounts and since it is based on digital money the banker can
just extract those digital funds by using the AI and leave, which is similar as a Ponzi Scheme.
This will lead to a corporate governance problem in the bank, and who is to
blame? Obviously, the CEO, directors and senior managers.
This is terrifying how people can use
technological power on manipulating the business and banking industry. However,
I would recommend that, to preserve ethics and clients safety, those AI program
should be monitored by the government, Accounting Standard Board and Securities
of Exchange Commission, because it would be effective that the AI is under the
control of the government to prevent financial exploitation and manipulation.
A
solution to prevent financial reporting and revenue manipulation I would
suggest the government such as Financial Accounting Standard Board should
provide a quarterly auditing process by using an auditing software on company’s
financial report, accounting report and internal managerial report to ensure
viability and integrity, based on authenticity of the reports and if there are
misleading information detected the FASB may provide penalties on the fraud.
Furthermore, a substantive research should be provided to the company’s
stakeholder and account transaction, such as in the manner of Wells Fargo
fraud, the FASB should interview the directors, employees and external
stakeholder such as other banks, customers and other stakeholder on Wells Fargo
activities, which the FASB should detect the fraud easily when the employee
confess on the pressure working in Wells Fargo and customers high fees,
expenses and unauthorised credit and debit transactions.
Another personal idea is that accounting and financial regulatory bodies should use AI to detect fraud and sustain sufficient corporate governance, such as AI should detect financial reporting manipulation in revenue manipulation, asset manipulation and financial transaction, and operational activities, with the objective on protecting stakeholders and prevent losses. Hence, AI can investigate a company's financial and operational activities in detail, including activities that are difficult to be detected by our eyes, including detecting Ponzi Schemes and fake accounts would be easier, as AI has the potential to extract information regarding an entity easily based on public information.
Another personal idea is that accounting and financial regulatory bodies should use AI to detect fraud and sustain sufficient corporate governance, such as AI should detect financial reporting manipulation in revenue manipulation, asset manipulation and financial transaction, and operational activities, with the objective on protecting stakeholders and prevent losses. Hence, AI can investigate a company's financial and operational activities in detail, including activities that are difficult to be detected by our eyes, including detecting Ponzi Schemes and fake accounts would be easier, as AI has the potential to extract information regarding an entity easily based on public information.



Hi~Max,that's a really good blog.But I still have some questions to ask you.
BalasHapusThe trust that is discussed in business, do you think that the constraint of morality itself is important or the treaty that is enacted is important? How can banking effectively build trust in different aspects?If the public don't trust banking companies ,what would happen?
Hey YuJie, you have a great question there. I think that both morality and treaty enforcement in a company are important because both is to establish ethical role and corporate governance. But the question is that will a company act responsibly even though they created internal laws? The answer is no, there will always unforeseen fraud in a company, such as financial data and report manipulation which is difficult to identify. It should be easy for banks to establish trust, such as being honest to stakeholders in providing financial information, banking data’s and other reports even if the company is not doing well. But the problem with big banks are their huge ego which accumulate fraud. If the public don't trust banks anymore then it will create the next " great depression", because we need banks to enhance world economy by transferring funds domestically and internationally to drive spending and investment, paying expenses and debt efficiently, to prevent inflation, and creating jobs. Such as some banks perform ethical investment to create more branch or businesses which increase employment, lending money for company’s growth and issuing debt securities to enhance the people's wealth. But it's the banks management responsibility to make ethical decision and performing those ethical roles appropriately
HapusActually, it is a great idea using AI to deal with data and supervision. I wann ask that how about the data collection, should government take another way to check the accuracy of data?
BalasHapusHey Shuang thank you for your question. Since in my vision that companies may use AI to store data and perform operations, I suggest that those AI supposed to be launch by the government so the AI could not be manipulated. But even if there is a cyber-attack on the AI government could prevent that or counter the situation, because the AI should be advance technology to counter cyber issue. Other than checking data perform by the AI to see the Viability of it, regulatory bodies such as government official auditors can use auditing program and physical analysis of company’s data by reading the company’s corporate reports and interview the executives regarding daily operations to be recorded.
HapusThank you
Nice blog, but i'm curious what is the reason for Wells Fargo to perform fraud at the first place? and why the executive weren't aware of the fraud?
BalasHapusHi Michael, thank you very much for your question and it is difficult to analyse the actual objective for companies such as Wells Fargo on attempting fraud besides greed. However, in the current 2016 situation the Basel Committee of Banking Supervision launch the new Basel 4 regulation of Fundamental Review of the Trading Book which restrict banks on loans transfer, minimize OTC Derivative contract issuance, pursuing safe investment and seize risky investment, and obtaining many simulated testing such as Back testing on Profit & Loss attribution test which banks failed 70% of the test having high insufficient financial data, and banks having difficulty in Stress testing to be expose on economic instability and having illiquidity caused by low capital funds. Overall signifying banks are force to increase capital by regulators that will reduce Return on Equity to 34%, profits and investment capital, thus Wells Fargo might be frustrated on this regulation thus providing fraud by maximizing revenues and employment commission by illegal accounts fees charges.
Hapus